Crude returns: How low oil prices have broken the relationship to food prices

Until recently, the price of crude oil and food moved largely in tandem. Since 2005 the correlation coefficient between the two price series (sourced from the IMF) has been +0.84. However, since late 2014 food prices have significantly outperformed crude oil prices.

Chart: Crude oil versus food prices

2016-02-19_0641

Note: The IMF food price index includes cereal, vegetable oils, meat, seafood, sugar, bananas and oranges while their crude oil price index is an average of Brent, WTI and Dubai.

Energy is a vital component of a farm’s operating costs. Direct energy consumption includes the use of diesel, electricity, propane, natural gas and renewable fuels for activities on the farm. Indirect energy consumption includes the use of fuel and feedstock (especially natural gas) in the manufacturing of agricultural chemicals, such as fertilisers and pesticides.

Energy makes up a significant part of operating costs for most crops. This is especially true when considering indirect energy expenditure on fertiliser because the production of fertiliser is extremely energy intensive, requiring large amounts of natural gas. For some crops – like oats, corn, wheat and barley – the combined cost of energy and fertiliser make up more than half of the total operating expenses in the US. The proportion of direct to indirect energy use varies by crop though. Corn, for example, is an energy input for ethanol production; it has relatively low direct fuel costs but has the highest percentage of fertiliser costs.

Meanwhile, with certain agricultural commodities now seen as substitutes to oil, as they are being diverted into biofuel production this allows the transmission of higher oil prices and volatility to affect agricultural prices directly.

The chart above might imply that food prices have further to fall, by as much as 60% if the trend since 2005 is to be believed. However, could something more fundamental be happening?

With oil prices back to 2003 levels we need to take a much longer term perspective. And it appears that perhaps oil and energy prices are just not as important in driving food prices as they once were. Between 1995 and 2004 the correlation between oil and food prices was -0.13. Looking at the chart below shows how energy prices diverged from food prices, starting in 1999, and then only in the past couple years coming back into line following the drop in the oil price.

2016-02-19_0642

(Visited 478 times, 10 visits today)
Unlock commodity market insight now and subscribe to our email updates or